Same Jordan card, same grade, $610 apart Monday

Two PSA 9 copies of the 1988-89 Fleer #17 Jordan drew 30 and 31 bids Monday, then closed at $1,075.00 and $465.00.
Two PSA 9 copies of the 1988-89 Fleer #17 Michael Jordan closed on eBay Monday at $1,075.00 and $465.00. Both were open auctions — 30 bids on the dearer copy, 31 bids on the cheaper one.
Why it matters
Same card, same grader, same numeric grade, both settled by competitive bidding on one day. There is no grading premium, no parallel and no disclosed damage to explain the difference — which makes this the cleanest kind of price evidence this column can print, and the rarest. It was the only pair of the day where two identically graded copies cleared our spread floor.
By the numbers
- $610.00 — the gap between the two contested PSA 9 copies, a 2.31x spread.
- $950.00 — what a third PSA 9 copy of the same card fetched the same day, at a fixed price that drew no bids.
- 13 of 41 — same-card pairs that cleared every gate Monday; 12 are in the table below.
| Card | Dearer sale | Cheaper sale | Gap | Multiple |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2003-04 Topps #221 LeBron James | PSA 10 — $6,950.00 [12] | ungraded — $1,200.00 [0] | $5,750.00 | 5.79x |
| 1996-97 Stadium Club Special Forces #SF4 Michael Jordan | PSA 8 — $2,199.99 [0] | ungraded — $395.00 [19] | $1,804.99 | 5.57x |
| 1988-89 Fleer All-Star #120 Michael Jordan | PSA 9 — $1,875.00 [35] | ungraded — $345.00 [37] | $1,530.00 | 5.43x |
| 2008-09 Topps #23 LeBron James | PSA 10 — $1,698.00 [25] | ungraded — $319.99 [0] | $1,378.01 | 5.31x |
| 1995-96 SkyBox Premium Electrified #278 Michael Jordan | PSA 9 — $1,261.00 [22] | ungraded — $450.00 [0] | $811.00 | 2.8x |
| 1987-88 Fleer Sticker #2 Michael Jordan | PSA 8 — $1,075.00 [17] | ungraded — $389.00 [35] | $686.00 | 2.76x |
| 2003-04 eTopps #43 LeBron James | BGS 9.5 — $1,200.00 [0] | ungraded — $515.87 [24] | $684.13 | 2.33x |
| 1988-89 Fleer #17 Michael Jordan | PSA 9 — $1,075.00 [30] | ungraded — $450.00 [25] | $625.00 | 2.39x |
| 1988-89 Fleer #17 Michael Jordan | PSA 9 — $1,075.00 [30] | PSA 9 — $465.00 [31] | $610.00 | 2.31x |
| 1996 Fleer Ultra Board Game #7 Michael Jordan | PSA 7 — $685.99 [0] | ungraded — $338.00 [18] | $347.99 | 2.03x |
| 1993-94 Topps Finest #1 Michael Jordan | PSA 9 — $660.00 [0] | ungraded — $325.00 [0] | $335.00 | 2.03x |
| 1998-99 Topps Gold Label #GL1 Michael Jordan | PSA 9 — $580.00 [0] | ungraded — $285.00 [0] | $295.00 | 2.04x |
Zoom in
The widest gap of the day was elsewhere, and it is softer than it looks. A PSA 10 2003-04 Topps #221 LeBron James rookie took 12 bids and closed at $6,950.00 against an ungraded copy at $1,200.00 — but that ungraded copy never drew a bid. An ungraded copy that did draw bidding, 62 bids of it, closed at $985.00 the same day.
Reality check
Monday’s other same-grade auctions barely moved. Two PSA 9 copies of the 1997-98 Metal Universe #23 Jordan drew 28 and 30 bids and closed at $3,300.00 and $3,100.00 — 1.06x. Two PSA 6 copies of the 1986-87 Fleer #57 Jordan rookie drew 56 and 28 bids and closed at $10,577.00 and $10,105.00 — 1.05x. Both pairs were blocked as too narrow to be worth writing about. That is the normal state of this market.
What's next
Read the bid counts before the spread. Where both sides of a pair were contested auctions, the gap is a market fact; where one side never drew a bid, part of it is an asking price somebody met. We run this comparison across sports collectibles every day — Sunday’s edition is here.
Sold for $1,075. Would you buy at this price?
1988-89 Fleer Basketball #17 Michael Jordan Chicago Bulls HOF PSA 9 LOOKS GEM
How we track this
RazMania compares completed eBay sales of the same card that closed on the same day. Two sales are treated as the same card only when the player, year, set, card number, parallel or photo variation, print-run serial, autograph status and altered status all match — so a Refractor is never compared against a base card. Best Offer sales are excluded entirely, because eBay publishes the seller’s asking price on those and never the settled figure; every price here is a confirmed paid price. Multi-card lots, reprints and customs are filtered out. We quote no comparable-sales median and no 90-day pool — both prices in every comparison closed on the same day. eBay reports sold date, not sold time. One further pair cleared every automated check and was withheld by hand: the cheaper copy’s listing disclosed a surface scratch, so the two sides are not a like-for-like comparison.
