A Graded Jordan Sold Below Its Own Raw Copy

Three copies of one 1995-96 Skybox Premium insert closed Tuesday: a PSA 9 at $933.00, a raw copy at $428.00, and a BGS 8 at $343.00.
A PSA 9 copy of the 1995-96 Skybox Premium Electrified #278 Michael Jordan sold for $933.00 on Tuesday. An ungraded copy of the same card closed the same day at $428.00. A BGS 8 copy closed lower than either of them, at $343.00.
Why it matters
The grading premium is not a ladder you climb one notch at a time. On this card, on this day, the middle grade finished last: the BGS 8 drew 20 bids and still closed under a raw copy that drew 4. If you are weighing a mid-grade submission, that is the read — the slab has to clear both the grading fee and the raw market, and on a 1990s insert it may clear neither.
By the numbers
- $933.00 against $428.00 — 2.18x apart on a $505.00 gap, and both were contested auctions, at 16 and 4 bids.
- $343.00 on 20 bids — the BGS 8. More bidders than the PSA 9 and the raw copy drew between them, and a lower price than both.
- 9 of 28 — same-card pairs that cleared the spread and gap floors, out of every pair found across both players.
| Card | Dearer sale | Cheaper sale | Gap | Multiple |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1995-96 Skybox Premium Electrified #278 Michael Jordan | PSA 9 — $933.00 [16] | $428.00 [4] | $505.00 | 2.18x |
| 2003-04 Bowman Rookies & Stars Chrome #123 LeBron James | PSA 8 — $955.00 [20] | $510.00 [25] | $445.00 | 1.87x |
| 1997-98 Metal Universe #23 Michael Jordan | PSA 8 — $1,036.00 [22] | $610.00 [25] | $426.00 | 1.7x |
| 1987-88 Fleer Sticker #2 Michael Jordan | PSA 8 — $1,045.00 [0] | PSA 8 — $787.00 [23] | $258.00 | 1.33x |
| 1992 Upper Deck #23 Michael Jordan | PSA 10 — $750.00 [0] | PSA 10 — $516.50 [22] | $233.50 | 1.45x |
| 1988-89 Fleer #17 Michael Jordan | PSA 9 (OC) — $600.00 [1] | $394.78 [33] | $205.22 | 1.52x |
| 1996-97 SkyBox E-X2000 #9 Michael Jordan | BGS 8.5 — $800.00 [0] | $320.00 [19] | $480.00 | 2.5x |
| 1993-94 Fleer Ultra Power in the Key #2 Michael Jordan | CGC 9.5 — $1,225.00 [29] | $400.00 [0] | $825.00 | 3.06x |
| 1988-89 Fleer All-Star Team #120 Michael Jordan | PSA 9 (OC) — $999.99 [0] | $362.25 [0] | $637.74 | 2.76x |
Zoom in
1997-98 Metal Universe #23 gave the cleanest reading of the day. Two PSA 8 copies closed at $1,036.00 and $1,000.00 — $36.00 apart, on 22 bids each. Ungraded copies of the same card closed at $610.00 and $515.00. The step from raw to slab was 1.7x and $426.00; the step between two identical slabs was $36.00. That is what a settled market for one card in one grade looks like — and why a wide same-grade gap usually means the two cards are not the same card.
Reality check
The biggest numbers of the day are the weakest ones. A CGC 9.5 1993-94 Fleer Ultra Power in the Key #2 sold for $1,225.00 on 29 bids against an ungraded copy at $400.00 — the widest multiple and the widest dollar gap on the board, at 3.06x and $825.00. But that $400.00 was a fixed-price sale that drew no bidding, so the low end of that gap is one seller’s asking price somebody met, not a contest. Four of Tuesday’s nine pairs had a dearer side that drew no bids at all. Read the bid counts before the multiples — more sports collectibles coverage and the September 22 edition show how the test reads on other days.
Sold for $933. Would you buy at this price?
1995-96 Skybox Premium Electrified #278 Michael Jordan — PSA 9
How we track this
RazMania compares completed eBay sales of the same card that closed on the same day. Two sales are treated as the same card only when the player, year, set, card number, parallel or photo variation, print-run serial, autograph status and altered status all match — so a Refractor is never compared against a base card. Best Offer sales are excluded entirely, because eBay publishes the seller’s asking price on those and never the settled figure; every price here is a confirmed paid price. Multi-card lots, reprints and customs are filtered out. We quote no comparable-sales median and no 90-day pool — both prices in every comparison closed on the same day. eBay reports sold date, not sold time.
