Same LeBron Rookie, Two Auctions, $3,070 Apart

The ungraded copy drew more bidders than the PSA 9 — and still closed $3,070.00 lower.
Two copies of the 2003-04 Topps Chrome #111 LeBron James rookie closed in open auctions on Wednesday: a PSA 9 at $4,920.00 and an ungraded copy at $1,850.00. Both were contested — 32 bids on the slab, 45 on the raw card.
Why it matters
Neither figure is an asking price somebody agreed to. Two separate rooms of bidders priced the same card on the same day, which is the cleanest read on a grading premium this column can produce. Of the 3 same-card pairs we found on Wednesday, it is the only one with live bidding on both sides.
By the numbers
- $4,920.00 — what the PSA 9 copy took, on 32 bids.
- $1,850.00 — what the ungraded copy took, on 45 bids.
- 2.66x — the spread between them, a $3,070.00 gap.
| Card | Copy | Price | Bids | Format |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2003-04 Topps Chrome #111 | PSA 9 | $4,920.00 | 32 | Auction |
| 2003-04 Topps Chrome #111 | Ungraded | $1,850.00 | 45 | Auction |
| 2003-04 Bowman #123 | PSA 8 | $849.85 | 0 | Fixed price |
| 2003-04 Bowman #123 | Ungraded | $560.00 | 15 | Auction |
Zoom in
The cheaper card was the more contested one: 45 bids landed on the raw copy against 32 on the slab. The day’s other publishable pair ran the same way with less force — a PSA 8 2003-04 Bowman #123 LeBron rookie sold at $849.85 as a fixed-price listing with no bidding, while an ungraded copy drew 15 bids and closed at $560.00, a 1.52x spread on a $289.85 gap. A slab is a condition call somebody else already made. A raw card asks the bidder to make it, and on Wednesday plenty of them wanted to.
Reality check
Most of a 2.66x gap is the grade itself, and that is not news — a PSA 9 carries a premium over a raw copy of the same card, and readers already expect it. Nobody found a bargain here. The one same-grade comparison we tracked went the other way: two PSA 10 copies of a 1991 Upper Deck #SP1 Michael Jordan sold at $1,700.00 and $1,535.00, 1.11x apart on a $165.00 gap. Both fell short of our 1.25x and $200 floors, so neither was published. Where the label matched exactly, the market agreed with itself. Where it did not, the same cardboard ran 2.66x apart. More of these in the sports collectibles desk, including the same rookie two days earlier.
Sold for $4,920. Would you buy at this price?
LEBRON JAMES PSA 9 2003-04 TOPPS CHROME #111 ROOKIE CARD RC CAVALIERS MINT 4108
How we track this
RazMania compares completed eBay sales of the same card that closed on the same day. Two sales are treated as the same card only when the player, year, set, card number, parallel or photo variation, print-run serial, autograph status and altered status all match — so a Refractor is never compared against a base card. Best Offer sales are excluded entirely, because eBay publishes the seller’s asking price on those and never the settled figure; every price here is a confirmed paid price. Multi-card lots, reprints and customs are filtered out. We quote no comparable-sales median and no 90-day pool — both prices in every comparison closed on the same day. eBay reports sold date, not sold time.
