Five 1986 Fleer Jordan rookies clear in one day

The five most notable Michael Jordan sales on Tuesday were all the same card, the 1986 Fleer #57 rookie, spread across four grades.
Every one of the five most notable Michael Jordan card sales on Tuesday was a 1986 Fleer #57 rookie. The largest figure among them, a PSA 9 listed at $70,000, closed on an accepted best offer — so the number eBay shows is the asking price, not what changed hands.
Why it matters
The day’s biggest figure and its biggest confirmed sale were two different cards, and only one of them is a price somebody paid. Tuesday’s top confirmed paid sale across our sports collectibles tracking was a 1985-86 Star #117 in BGS 9, which took 29 bids to reach $12,600.
By the numbers
- 390 — qualifying single-card Jordan sales tracked on Tuesday. 303 of them were confirmed paid, for a combined $408,667.09.
- $718.02 — the confirmed-paid median for the day. A separate 87 best-offer listings carried $176,246.71 in asking prices that were never settled publicly.
- 63 bids — the most contested card of the day, a 1998-99 Upper Deck insert that finished at $715.55. The $70,000 listing drew 0.
Zoom in
Four 1986 Fleer #57 rookies changed hands at confirmed prices on the same day, and the spread tracks the slab: $10,300 for a PSA 6 on 30 bids, $10,100 for a second PSA 6 on 35 bids, $7,100 for a PSA 4 on 45 bids, and $4,000 for a PSA-encapsulated copy graded authentic-altered, carrying no numeric grade, on 48 bids. Note which way the bidding ran: the cheaper the slab, the more bidders chased it. The same rookie led Monday’s column.
Reality check
A listed price is not a completed trade. eBay publishes the asking price on an accepted best offer and never the settled figure, which is why the $70,000 sits outside every paid total above — the same reason you read the last print rather than the offer side of a quote, a distinction that also runs through our source-linked research on the stock side. The comparable-sales pool is no help here either: 108 listings matching the 1986 Fleer #57 spanned $19.99 to $54,000, which is several different things averaged together, not one card’s market. No median drawn from it is worth quoting, so this column is not quoting one.
What's next
Four confirmed #57 sales in a day is a dense enough cluster to sketch the grade curve, but it is one day and should not be read as a trend. Watch whether PSA 4 through PSA 6 copies keep pulling more bidders than the high-grade slabs.
Sold for $70,000. Would you buy at this price?
1986 Fleer #57 Michael Jordan Rookie, PSA 9
How we track this
RazMania monitors completed eBay sales daily, filtering out multi-card lots, reprints and cross-listed items to isolate genuine single-card sales. This edition covers 390 qualifying single-card Michael Jordan sales on September 22, 2026, of which 303 were confirmed paid. Best-offer listings are shown at the seller’s asking price because eBay never publishes the settled figure, and they are excluded from every paid total here. The comparable-sales pool for the lead card was rejected as too contaminated to quote a median. eBay reports sold date, not sold time.
