$10,900: Genius or Idiot?

47 bidders pushed a PSA 7 Gengar to 1.27x its own matched-comp median, and the pool behind that median is 8 sales deep.
A PSA 7 copy of the 1999 Japanese Vending Masaki Promo Gengar, card #94, sold at auction for $10,900 after 47 bids. That is $2,315 above the median of the 8 matched sales of the same card in the same grade.
Why it matters
Comp deviation is the heaviest plank in this model, and it is the plank this purchase fails: comp deviation 22 of 40 for a 1.27x fill. Read that median with care, though. The matched pool came back at 8 sales, exactly our floor of 8, so it is thin and weakly supported.
By the numbers
- 1.27x — what the winner paid against the $8,585 matched-comp median, a $2,315 premium.
- 8 matched sales — the whole comparable set, running $7,600 to $9,600 with an interquartile ratio of 1.15.
- 47 bids — this price was contested, not posted.
The intrigue
Price discovery 15 of 15 is the strongest reading on this card, and it is earned: 47 bidders competed to set the number. Trend 9 of 15 reflects a pool clearing 4.8% higher across its 3 recent sales than over the full window. Scarcity 0 of 15 is the honest half, with no serial numbering, no autograph and a mid-grade holder.
Reality check
Paid 1.27x the matched-comp median, this is not a bargain. Liquidity 3 of 15 says the same thing from the other side: 8 matched sales is a thin exit, and a thin exit is what turns a 1.27x entry into a problem. The middle of the pool is tight at $8,110 to $9,300, but the whole pool runs $7,600 to $9,600. A Gengar that cleared at a different grade shows how far one holder grade moves this market.
What's next
49 of 100, FAIR BUY, no cap applied. Components: comp deviation 22 of 40, trend 9 of 15, liquidity 3 of 15, price discovery 15 of 15, scarcity 0 of 15. Watch whether the next matched sales close above or below $8,585. Three inputs are absent by design: no population report, no sell-through, and no card-level search volume. The rest of the daily card sales coverage sits here.
Sold for $10,900. Would you buy at this price?
1999 Pokemon Japanese Vending Masaki Promo #94 Gengar Holo, PSA 7
How we track this
RazMania reads completed eBay sales daily and strips out multi-card lots, reprints, altered slabs and accepted best offers, so every price quoted here is one somebody actually paid. The comparable median on this card is computed from 8 verified sales matched on year, card number, grader and grade, with the lead sale itself excluded from its own pool. The comparable pull requests a 90-day window and this brief does not record the span it received, so no window is claimed. eBay reports sold date, not sold time.
