Sports Collectibles

$8,000: Genius or Idiot?

September 27, 2026
2009 Pokemon Japanese Advent of Arceus 1st Edition #043 Gengar LV.X holo in PSA 10 — sold for $8,000 on eBay
2 min read

A 1st Edition Gengar in PSA 10 drew 43 bids and closed at $8,000 — under every one of the 9 matched sales we could verify.

Someone paid $8,000 for a 2009 Pokemon Japanese Advent of Arceus 1st Edition #043 Gengar LV.X holo in PSA 10, after 43 bids in an open auction. The comp model scores it 63 of 100: FAIR BUY.

Why it matters

That $8,000 sits below the $8,200 floor of its own matched pool — the buyer filled under every comparable sale we verified, not just under the median. The pool is thin, though: 9 sales is barely past our own floor of 8, so the median is weakly supported and the discount inherits that weakness.

By the numbers

  • 0.82x — what the buyer paid against the $9,800 matched-comp median, a gap of $1,800.
  • 9 matched sales — the entire pool, $8,200 to $14,900, 1 self-row excluded.
  • 43 bids — an open auction, not a quiet fixed-price fill.

The intrigue

Price discovery 15 of 15 is the strongest reading this model gives, and the case rests on it. 43 bidders competed and still settled at 0.82x the matched median — a discount set by an open auction, not by one buyer’s opinion. Comp deviation 36 of 40 follows. Nothing in the pool is ambiguous: all 9 titles name the same set, the same 1st Edition, the same #043 and the same PSA 10, at an interquartile spread of 1.19x.

Reality check

Liquidity 3 of 15 and trend 5 of 15 are where it weakens. Trend reads -7.1% across the 5 recent sales in the window, so this card has been softening, and a fill under the median in a falling market is partly the market moving rather than a buy well made. Scarcity 4 of 15 rests on the PSA 10 alone — no serial numbering, no autograph. And 9 sales is a narrow exit, set by the same 9 that set the median. One cleared $14,900 against an $8,200 floor.

What's next

Score 63 of 100, verdict FAIR BUY, no cap applied. Watch whether the next copies clear nearer the $9,100 first quartile or the $8,200 floor — that settles whether -7.1% was noise or direction. Read the score for what it is not, too: no population report behind it, no sell-through data, no card-level search volume. It prices one sale against 9 verified sales of the same card in the same grade. Also worth reading: yesterday’s edition, and more card sales we have verified.

Your call

Sold for $8,000. Would you buy at this price?

2009 Pokemon Japanese Advent of Arceus 1st Edition #043 Gengar LV.X Holo, PSA 10

Would you buy at this price?

How we track this

RazMania walks that day’s confirmed single-card sales in descending price order and leads on the first one it can match against comparable sales of the same card in the same grade. Best-offer listings are dropped, because eBay publishes the asking price on those and never the settled figure. This edition’s median comes from 9 verified sales of the same card and grade, and the lead sale itself was excluded from its own pool. The comparable pull requests a 90-day window; we do not assert the span it actually returned. eBay reports sold date, not sold time.

Share: