$13,100: Genius or Idiot?

A PSA 10 Snorlax from the 1998 Japanese Vending set drew 37 bids and closed at 1.44x its own comparable-sale median.
A 1998 Pokemon Japanese Vending Series 1 #143 Snorlax, graded PSA 10, sold for $13,100 on October 22 after 37 bids. Against 12 matched sales of the same card in the same grade, the median is $9,095.
Why it matters
The buyer paid a $4,005 premium over the only baseline this card has, and did it in open bidding rather than at a fixed price — so the room set that number, not one person. It was not the biggest sale we tracked that day. More completed sales land daily on our sports collectibles hub.
By the numbers
- $13,100 — the price paid, or 1.44x the $9,095 matched-comp median.
- 37 bids — competitive price discovery, and the strongest part of the score at 15 of 15.
- 12 matched sales — the comp pool, running $6,499 to $12,300 at an interquartile spread of 1.08.
The intrigue
The bull case is that the card is re-rating and the median is lagging it. The pool’s recent sales run 2.2% above its full-window median, on 6 of the 12, so the drift is upward. The pool is also clean for a Japanese promo: an interquartile spread of 1.08 means the middle of it clusters tightly on one card in one grade. And we priced this same card in this same grade last month — it is back on the board with more bidders behind it.
Reality check
$13,100 is above every one of the 12 matched sales: the pool’s own maximum is $12,300. No prior sale of this card at this grade supports this price. Liquidity scored 6 of 15 for a reason: 12 sales is a working exit, not a deep one, and a seller in a hurry would be selling into a market that has never paid this much. One hot auction is a data point, not a new level.
What's next
The score is 56 of 100: comp deviation 22 of 40, trend 9 of 15, liquidity 6 of 15, price discovery 15 of 15, scarcity 4 of 15. The verdict is FAIR BUY — a perfect 15 of 15 on bidding could not offset paying 1.44x the median, which is the design of the scale. The score uses no population report, no sell-through data and no card-level search volume; we do not have them and will not estimate them. Watch whether the next PSA 10 of this card clears $12,300.
Between the lines
The biggest sale we tracked that day was a 2005 Pokemon EX Emerald #60 Pikachu reverse foil in PSA 9 at $100,000 — the biggest we saw, not necessarily the market’s largest, because both category browses hit their 1,000-row cap, which makes every count here a floor rather than a total. We walked past 24 more expensive sales first. Of those, 21 had too few comparable sales to quote a median against our floor of 8, one returned a pool spanning visibly different cards, and two could not be pinned to a specific enough query. None was screened out for free: every refusal above this card was paid for.
Sold for $13,100. Would you buy at this price?
1998 Pokemon Japanese Vending Series 1 #143 Snorlax, PSA 10
How we track this
RazMania monitors completed eBay sales daily, dropping multi-card lots, reprints, altered cards and Best Offer sales, where eBay publishes the seller’s asking price rather than the figure actually settled on. Prices are confirmed sold prices. This verdict rests on 12 matched sales of the same card in the same grade, with the lead sale itself excluded from its own comp pool; the comp pull requests a trailing window and does not record the span it received, so no window is claimed here. The market-wide counts come from two category browses that both returned exactly their 1,000-row cap, so they are floors, not totals. eBay reports sold date, not sold time.
