Trading card

Josh Allen and Patrick Mahomes Cards Tie at $97,600 at Goldin

November 17, 2026
A brown leather American football resting on grass
2 min read

A Josh Allen card and a Patrick Mahomes card each sold for $97,600 at Goldin on Nov. 14, tying for the top spot on Sports Illustrated’s Week 10 list of football card sales, published Nov. 15. The Allen is a 2025 Topps Chrome NFL Honors Gold Shield numbered to just 3, and the Mahomes is a 2017 Panini National Treasures Stars & Stripes graded BGS 9.5.

The two cards at the top

The Allen card comes from Topps’ NFL Honors line and was sold in Topps’ encased format, according to SI. It is numbered /3. SI did not list a grade.

The Mahomes card is a 2017 National Treasures Stars & Stripes card. SI lists its grade as BGS 9.5 and its sale at Goldin on the same day.

SI writer D. Allen Thompson gave Allen the top line anyway: “Welcome to #1 Josh Allen; whether it is a tie or not, it still counts.”

A Topps Allen numbered to 3 and a Panini Mahomes graded BGS 9.5 sold for exactly the same price on the same day.

The rest of the top 5

Tom Brady filled 2 of the other 3 spots, per SI:

  • 2000 Upper Deck SP Authentic Tom Brady, PSA 10: $91,500 at Goldin. SI’s list dates this sale “Nov. 14, 2025”; the other 4 sales and the article are dated 2026, so the year may be a typo, but SI has not corrected it.
  • 1986 Topps Jerry Rice #161, PSA 10: $85,000 through Fanatics Buy Now on Nov. 10.
  • 2008 Topps Finest Moments Superfractor 1/1 Tom Brady, PSA 10: $84,180 at Goldin on Nov. 14.

SI said the 2008 Brady’s PSA 10 grade plus an MBA Silver Diamond certification puts it on “that short list” of standout cards.

Context from the week

The sales came in the same week Topps prepared to release 2026 Topps Chrome Football on Nov. 18, according to Sports Collectors Daily’s release calendar. The calendar says standard hobby boxes hold 20 four-card packs and 1 autograph, and jumbo boxes hold 12 packs of 11 cards with 2 autographs.

By the numbers

  • $97,600: Price of both the Allen and the Mahomes
  • /3: Print run of the Allen Gold Shield
  • BGS 9.5: Grade of the Mahomes National Treasures card
  • $91,500: SP Authentic Brady PSA 10
  • $85,000: 1986 Topps Jerry Rice PSA 10
  • $84,180: 2008 Finest Moments Brady Superfractor PSA 10
  • 4 of 5: Top sales that closed at Goldin

What collectors are watching

  • Allen’s modern 1-of-few cards: Whether low-numbered Honors and Chrome parallels keep landing near the top of weekly charts.
  • Mahomes’ 2017 high-end cards: How National Treasures copies compare with this BGS 9.5 result.
  • Topps Chrome Football: The Nov. 18 release adds a new wave of NFL Chrome cards to the market.
  • 2 Brady cards: A 2000 SP Authentic and a 2008 Finest Moments Superfractor both cleared $84,000 on SI’s list.

Why it matters

In our view, a tie at the top shows how closely high-end buyers are pricing Allen and Mahomes right now, with a 2025 card numbered to 3 matching a graded 2017 Mahomes. SI’s list covers sales through Nov. 14, and the next set of Goldin results will show whether either name pulls ahead.

Sources: Sports Illustrated (Nov. 15, 2026); Sports Collectors Daily (Nov. 11, 2026)

Featured image: Photo by Dave Adamson on Unsplash

Your call

Would you buy at this price?

Josh Allen and Patrick Mahomes Cards Tie at $97,600 at Goldin

Would you buy at this price?
Share: