Sports Collectibles

Jordan rookie draws 44 bids, sells for $26,600

October 1, 2026
1986-87 Fleer Michael Jordan #57 rookie card in a BGS 9 holder — sold for $26,600 on eBay
2 min read

The BGS 9 rookie was not the day's largest sale, and 83 of 308 Jordan sales were accepted best offers — asking prices, not settled ones.

A 1986-87 Fleer Michael Jordan #57 rookie in a BGS 9 holder sold Wednesday for $26,600 after 44 bids. It was the most notable Jordan card sale RazMania tracked that day — and it was not the biggest.

Why it matters

We pick the lead on notability, not on price, and Wednesday those were two different cards. The day’s largest sale was a 1998-99 Skybox Thunder insert in BGS 9.5 that took 53 bids and brought $46,988. The rookie brought less and is still the card everything else in the Jordan market gets priced against — the 1986-87 Fleer #57 is the most important basketball card ever printed.

By the numbers

  • $26,600 — what the BGS 9 #57 brought at auction, on 44 bids.
  • 308 — qualifying single-card Jordan sales on the day. 225 were confirmed paid, totalling $403,137.67 at a $510 median.
  • 83 — of those 308 were accepted best offers, carrying $218,241.44 in asking prices rather than settled ones.

Zoom in

Attention and price moved separately. The most contested card of the day was not a five-figure rookie at all: a 1987-88 Fleer #59 in PSA 6 took 91 bids and sold for $765. The day’s largest asking price, $29,999.99 on a 1998 Skybox E-X Century insert in PSA 8, drew 0 bids and closed as an accepted offer. Open bidding and a negotiated deal are two mechanisms, and they produce two different qualities of signal.

Reality check

One sale is not a market, and this one is not a trend — Tuesday’s lead was a different card at a different price. We also refused to publish a comparable-sale multiple here: the baseline pool that came back spanned several different products and conditions, and a median drawn from it would have read as rigorous while being wrong. A comparable set that spans different assets is not a comparable set — the same mistake, wearing the same confidence, that the same evidence-led approach to stocks exists to avoid.

Your call

Sold for $26,600. Would you buy at this price?

1986-87 Fleer Michael Jordan #57 rookie card, BGS 9

Would you buy at this price?

How we track this

RazMania monitors completed eBay sales daily, filtering out multi-card lots, reprints, and cross-listed items to isolate genuine single-card sales. This edition covers the 308 qualifying Jordan single-card sales dated September 30, 2026. No comparable-sale median is quoted: the baseline pool for this card was rejected as too mixed to price against, so no multiple appears above. Our wider context sample spans 44 days, not 90. eBay reports sold date, not sold time.

Share: