Sports Collectibles

Jordan’s PSA 8 rookie sold below its own comps

August 26, 2026
1986 Fleer #57 Michael Jordan rookie in a PSA 8 slab, listed at $12,000 on eBay and sold through an accepted best offer
2 min read

A 1986 Fleer #57 in PSA 8 carried a $12,000 list price against a $19,249.50 median for the same card at the same grade.

A 1986 Fleer #57 Michael Jordan rookie graded PSA 8 changed hands Tuesday after the seller accepted a best offer against a $12,000 list price. Recent sales of that exact card at that exact grade run a $19,249.50 median — and the offer that closed this one settled somewhere below the $12,000 ask.

Why it matters

The 1986 Fleer #57 is the most important basketball card ever printed, and PSA 8 is the grade where most of the serious money in that card actually trades. When a copy clears under the recent median for its own grade, that is a data point about seller patience, not about the card falling out of favor.

By the numbers

  • $12,000 — the list price on the lead card. eBay publishes the asking price on a best-offer sale and never the accepted figure, so what was actually paid is lower and is not public.
  • $19,249.50 — the median across 14 unsigned, unaltered PSA 8 sales of the same card, spanning $10,500 to $21,500. That is a 2.05x range, tight enough to quote.
  • 0.62x — where the $12,000 ask sits against that median. The paid price sits lower again.

Zoom in

The day’s top confirmed paid sale was not the rookie. A 2013 Upper Deck All Time Greats “Team For The Ages” #TA14 Jordan on-card autograph, numbered /12, went at $9,850.99 on a straight buy-it-now with no bidding. The most contested lot of the day was far cheaper: a 1995 Fleer Flair Hardwood Leaders #4 in PSA 9 drew 36 bids and closed at $341.52.

The big picture

Across 25 qualifying single-card Jordan sales Tuesday, 22 were confirmed paid prices totaling $32,363.18 at a $538.37 median. The rookie and the /12 autograph carry most of the day’s dollars; the rest of the tape is ordinary. Our trailing-90-day sample of 159 Jordan sales runs a $499.00 median. For comparison, see the August 24 edition and the August 23 edition.

Reality check

This is one card, not a trend. The pool behind that $19,249.50 median is 14 sales — thin, and quotable only because every copy in it is the same card at the same grade. The broader 1986 Fleer pool for this card is unusable: 114 sales spanning $255 to $65,000, mixing grades and products, so no multiple is drawn from it. And the $12,000 is an asking price, not a receipt.

Your call

Sold for $12,000. Would you buy at this price?

Fleer 1986 Fleer Michael Jordan #57 PSA 8 Graded Card Chicago Bulls

Would you buy at this price?

How we track this

RazMania monitors completed eBay sales daily, filtering out multi-card lots, reprints, and cross-listed items to isolate genuine single-card sales. The comparable-sale median quoted here comes from 14 verified sales of the same card at the same grade, unsigned and unaltered, with the lead sale excluded. Best-offer sales are reported as list prices because eBay does not publish the accepted figure. eBay reports sold date, not sold time.

Share: