Jordan rookie draws 90 bids, sells under median

A PSA 5 1986 Fleer #57 pulled Monday's heaviest bidding on eBay and still closed at 0.82x the median for its own grade.
The most contested Michael Jordan card on eBay Monday was a PSA 5 copy of his 1986 Fleer #57 rookie, which drew 90 bids and closed at $8,500. That was the highest confirmed paid price of the day across the 39 qualifying single-card Jordan sales we tracked — and it still landed below what PSA 5 copies have been fetching.
Why it matters
The 1986 Fleer #57 is the most important basketball card ever printed, and PSA 5 is the grade where most working collectors actually shop. When the deepest bidding of the day lands under the recent median, that gap is the read — not the headline price.
By the numbers
- $8,500 — the hammer price, on 90 bids, in a straight auction. No best offer, no reserve games.
- $10,342.50 — the median of 8 comparable PSA 5 1986 Fleer #57 sales, unsigned and unaltered, with this sale excluded. Range: $9,024 to $13,226.
- 0.82x — what Monday’s sale worked out to against that median.
Zoom in
Bidding depth and price did not move together Monday. The Fleer rookie took 90 bids, the most of any Jordan card we tracked; a 1986 Fleer sticker of the same rookie, also PSA 5, drew 36 bids and closed at $1,625. And the day’s single largest figure, $9,299.99 on a 1985 Star Slam Dunk 5×7, was not a sale price at all — that listing accepted a best offer, and eBay publishes the asking price on those, never the number that was actually paid.
Reality check
This is one auction, not a trend. The comparable pool behind that median is 8 sales — thin enough that a single soft or strong result moves it, and the broader 1986 Fleer pool was too contaminated with mixed grades and formats to quote at all. Across the full day, 11 of the 39 qualifying sales were best offers carrying asking prices rather than settled ones, and the median confirmed paid sale was $488.88.
What's next
Watch whether PSA 5 #57 copies keep clearing five figures. Eight sales is enough to notice a $10,342.50 median and not enough to defend it — if the next several close nearer Monday’s $8,500, the grade has repriced rather than one buyer getting a good night. Our Sunday edition covered the previous session, and the listing itself is still viewable.
Sold for $8,500. Would you buy at this price?
MICHAEL JORDAN PSA 5 1986 FLEER BASKETBALL #57 ROOKIE CARD RC BULLS 3696
How we track this
RazMania monitors completed eBay sales daily, filtering out multi-card lots, reprints, and cross-listed items to isolate genuine single-card sales. Prices are final sold prices. The comparable-sale median here is calculated from 8 verified PSA 5 sales of the same card over the trailing 90 days, with this sale excluded. eBay reports sold date, not sold time.
